Hello There, Guest!  

Data sharing policy

#5
(2014-Apr-09, 08:09:23)Duxide Wrote: The author emails the dataset to reviewers before publication and posts it in the forum after publication. Readers do not need to see the file before the paper is published, only reviewers do.


This is one possible method, yes.

I disagree that only appointed reviewers need to see the file before. As I said, non-appointed reviewers may have valuable input too (e.g. error correction).

Currently, the policy is that datasets must be in the submission thread opening post. This is my preferred policy. Reviewers have however generally ignored this requirement and only demanded datasets just before publication, i.e. in line with your preferred policy.
 Reply
 
Messages In This Thread
Data sharing policy - by Emil - 2014-Apr-08, 16:55:09
RE: Data sharing: before or after publication? - by Duxide - 2014-Apr-08, 18:57:04
RE: Data sharing: before or after publication? - by Emil - 2014-Apr-09, 06:42:11
RE: Data sharing: before or after publication? - by Duxide - 2014-Apr-09, 08:09:23
RE: Data sharing: before or after publication? - by Emil - 2014-Apr-09, 09:51:15
RE: Data sharing: before or after publication? - by Duxide - 2014-Apr-09, 09:59:21
RE: Data sharing policy - by Meng Hu - 2014-May-12, 02:43:04
RE: Data sharing policy - by Emil - 2014-May-09, 15:13:54
RE: Data sharing policy - by csdunkel - 2014-May-10, 15:46:04
RE: Data sharing policy - by Emil - 2014-May-10, 18:40:31
RE: Data sharing policy - by Emil - 2014-May-10, 20:32:49
RE: Data sharing policy - by Emil - 2014-May-12, 03:13:24
RE: Data sharing policy - by Meng Hu - 2014-May-12, 16:10:10
RE: Data sharing policy - by Emil - 2014-May-30, 21:58:51
RE: Data sharing policy - by Meng Hu - 2014-Jun-01, 01:33:56
RE: Data sharing policy - by Emil - 2014-Jun-02, 01:45:09
 
Forum Jump:

Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)