Hello There, Guest!  

[ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration

#17
(2014-Apr-02, 11:53:16)Duxide Wrote: You wrote "A systematic review (not an unsystematic review,
such as that conducted in the paper) of rule-dependence numbers and Flynn effect magnitudes that corrects for these sources of error - viz., few tests, few raters, and unreliability - would probably yield a higher correlation"

Then do this. This paper as it currently stands is not publishable.
No definition of rule dependance is provided. None of the hypotheses is empirically tested. This looks like a summary of Woodley and Armstrong's paper and does not contribute anything substantially novel.
After the hypotheses have been tested, this paper might be published. But in its current form, it's not even close to being a rough draft.


As the author notes, it's not intended to be an empirical paper. It's what is sometimes called a "brief communication" or a "letter". Many journals don't like this kind of material since the cost of publication makes it not worth it. We, however, have 0 cost of publication (except for editor's time), so this is not a problem.
 Reply
 
Messages In This Thread
[ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Philbrick Bastinado - 2014-Mar-25, 03:48:38
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Philbrick Bastinado - 2014-Mar-30, 02:46:03
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Duxide - 2014-Mar-30, 10:24:54
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Philbrick Bastinado - 2014-Mar-30, 21:59:18
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Emil - 2014-Mar-30, 22:47:52
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Philbrick Bastinado - 2014-Mar-30, 22:55:11
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Emil - 2014-Mar-31, 00:15:31
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Philbrick Bastinado - 2014-Mar-31, 02:26:16
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Emil - 2014-Mar-31, 23:06:37
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Philbrick Bastinado - 2014-Mar-31, 23:35:07
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Emil - 2014-Apr-01, 01:24:19
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Philbrick Bastinado - 2014-Apr-01, 02:43:38
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Emil - 2014-Apr-01, 05:54:15
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Chuck - 2014-Apr-01, 18:07:25
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Philbrick Bastinado - 2014-Apr-02, 03:05:59
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Duxide - 2014-Apr-02, 11:53:16
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Emil - 2014-Apr-02, 18:06:30
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Duxide - 2014-Apr-02, 19:15:56
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Philbrick Bastinado - 2014-Apr-02, 19:27:55
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Duxide - 2014-Apr-02, 19:52:25
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Chuck - 2014-Apr-02, 20:55:54
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Emil - 2014-Apr-02, 21:04:07
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Philbrick Bastinado - 2014-Apr-03, 05:01:36
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Chuck - 2014-Apr-04, 10:49:41
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Duxide - 2014-Apr-03, 11:59:31
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Emil - 2014-Apr-03, 18:37:10
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Emil - 2014-Apr-04, 10:57:16
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Philbrick Bastinado - 2014-Apr-05, 00:42:13
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Emil - 2014-Apr-05, 00:50:06
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Philbrick Bastinado - 2014-Apr-05, 01:17:20
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Emil - 2014-Apr-05, 01:28:18
RE: [ODP] Rule dependence and Flynn effects: some elaboration - by Emil - 2015-Mar-06, 01:34:42
 
Forum Jump:

Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)