Hello There, Guest!  

Review Process

#2
Concerning the "one reviewer can review only one paper at a time" (i.e., no review about another paper until the first is published), I think it's better to trust the reviewers for not doing too much (more than he/she can handle). Personally, when I think I'm reviewing a lot of papers, I ensure that I can remember them. If it's highly complex, I will avoid doing multiple reviews at the same time. For most of Emil's paper, I understand them easily, so it's not difficult to remember what was in it, even after several weeks.

Perhaps this should be made clear by Emil right here or by Duxide right here for the recommendation lists and FAQ, that a reviewer is recommended not to review too many papers if he/she thinks he cannot remember them after a while. But I don't think it needs to be a strict requirement. Just a recommendation.

Finally, I agree that the most problematic thing here is that we don't have enough people. My impression is that any given reviewer will have more incitation and motivation if the submission thread has already started, i.e., someone else has read the entire paper and has commented on it. This way, one can read the comments, remarks, before looking at the entire article. That's a good way of having an impression of what's being written in the article, and get a first impression about the aim of the article.
 Reply
 
Messages In This Thread
Review Process - by Chuck - 2014-Dec-07, 18:48:19
RE: Review Process - by Meng Hu - 2014-Dec-08, 01:51:52
RE: Review Process - by Chuck - 2014-Dec-08, 03:07:15
RE: Review Process - by Emil - 2014-Dec-08, 02:21:46
RE: Review Process - by Chuck - 2014-Dec-08, 03:12:22
RE: Review Process - by Duxide - 2014-Dec-08, 13:19:05
RE: Review Process - by Guglielmo Da Venezia - 2014-Dec-08, 04:35:14
RE: Review Process - by Emil - 2014-Dec-08, 03:52:32
RE: Review Process - by Emil - 2014-Dec-08, 12:46:34
RE: Review Process - by Duxide - 2014-Dec-08, 13:26:51
RE: Review Process - by Meng Hu - 2014-Dec-08, 17:50:22
RE: Review Process - by Emil - 2014-Dec-08, 18:10:05
 
Forum Jump:

Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)