Hello There, Guest!  

[ODP] The personal Jensen coefficient does not predict grades beyond its association

#21
(2014-Oct-23, 17:43:47)Dalliard Wrote: 8) As a general point, the g factor is a between-individuals variable whereas your personal Jensen coefficient is a within-individual variable. You cannot easily generalize from individual differences processes to within-person processes, so your entire analysis is a bit suspect. Peter Molenaar has written about this a lot.


What was the title of the Molenaar's article ? I'm interesting in it.
 Reply
#22
(2014-Oct-30, 19:52:27)Dalliard Wrote: 1) "finding the correlation between subtests' g-loading and each person's scores on the subtests" --> g-loadingS


Fixed.

Quote:2) Rephrase: "I ran the partial correlations with GPA and g partialled out."

Rephrased to "I ran the partial correlations between each subtest and GPA with g partialled out."

Quote:4) I think there should be more reflection on the intra- versus inter-individual differences problem, but I approve publication in any case.

I don't understand what the problem is exactly, so I can't comment.

--

Added new revision, #8, dated 30th Oct.

https://osf.io/gb3cy/

--

There are 4 reviewer approvals:
Meng Hu - http://www.openpsych.net/forum/showthrea...99#pid1799
Piffer - http://www.openpsych.net/forum/showthrea...05#pid1805
Fuerst - http://www.openpsych.net/forum/showthrea...58#pid2058
Dalliard - http://www.openpsych.net/forum/showthrea...07#pid2107

I will do last edit for minor language corrections and publish.
 Reply
#23
Didn't find any errors. Published. http://openpsych.net/ODP/2014/10/the-per...on-with-g/

Moving thread...
 Reply
#24
(2014-Oct-30, 21:36:37)Meng Hu Wrote:
(2014-Oct-23, 17:43:47)Dalliard Wrote: 8) As a general point, the g factor is a between-individuals variable whereas your personal Jensen coefficient is a within-individual variable. You cannot easily generalize from individual differences processes to within-person processes, so your entire analysis is a bit suspect. Peter Molenaar has written about this a lot.


What was the title of the Molenaar's article ? I'm interesting in it.


There are many articles, one of them attached.


Attached Files
.pdf   The New Person-Specific Paradigm in Psychology.pdf (Size: 263.56 KB / Downloads: 437)
 Reply
 
Forum Jump:

Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)